{
  "version": "group-01r2",
  "question": "Can four people with different explicit scent demands stay at one table?",
  "program": "Shared documents and conversation in a lounge; tea preparation is an illustrative activity at the existing tracer source, not calibrated tea emissions.",
  "requirements": {
    "group": "Every member has a distinct free seat at the same existing table.",
    "approach": "Lower-layer 20-minute C* >=0.20; room-volume mean is an explicit diagnostic alternative.",
    "avoid": "Lower-layer 20-minute C* <=0.05; sensitivity0.001; report both metrics separately.",
    "hard": "Never relaxed by assignment.",
    "soft": "Reported separately as met/unmet; never converted to comfort or utility.",
    "real_participation": "Unknown: document legibility, hearing and experienced odour have not been measured. Table membership establishes layout candidates only."
  },
  "alternatives": {
    "A0": "Current geometry; background seats occupied in a deterministic round-robin over tables in each room. This is a constructed fragmentation scenario, not measured demand.",
    "A1": "Same geometry and same background population in each room; reserve four seats at the first table in each room before background arrivals. No person is relocated after arrival. Reservation is unavailable in a room if fewer than four seats remain in that room.",
    "why": "Compare scattered background, guided table sharing, and advance reservation at all declared populations. Retain physical layout; do not assume reservation is smallest.",
    "cost": "Reservation holds up to12seats; unconditional12seat reservation would reject max(0,n-88) background visitors. Implemented adaptive audit skips rooms with fewer than4free seats using known final population: capacity screening, not causal policy evaluation. Fill-first may conflict with desire to sit alone; no observed acceptance model.",
    "fill_first": "Same geometry and room populations; guide arrivals to already occupied tables first, reserving no seats. Requires willingness to share; that cost is unmeasured."
  },
  "scenarios": [
    "all approach required",
    "all avoid required",
    "avoid required + approach preferred + two neutral",
    "avoid required + approach required + two neutral"
  ],
  "background_occupancy": [
    0,
    40,
    46,
    54,
    70,
    88,
    96
  ],
  "diagnostic_amendment": "54 added after inspecting deterministic 46-occupant seat allocation: 46 still leaves two four-seat tables. 54 illustrates full fragmentation. This is a transparent constructed case, not a held-out statistical test or estimated occupancy frequency.",
  "counterexample": "Also compare clustered occupancy at 46 people; reservation must not be credited for solving a fragmentation problem that is absent.",
  "simultaneous_groups": "Enumerate 0..25 four-person groups with every split of approach/avoid groups; exact bipartite table matching. Tables and seats cannot be reused; full-table sharing with unrelated occupants is allowed, exclusivity is not assumed.",
  "decision": "Guided sharing is the first lower-commitment operating candidate where the declared hard demands permit it. Keep reservation as conditional comparison. Both depend on willingness to share and unknown real activity. No physical boundary change supported.",
  "boundary_gate": "A conflict between disjoint room-average requirements is impossible in this model. It does not establish physical impossibility at different seats of one table. Obtain one targeted same-table contrast observation before designing a boundary remedy.",
  "next_observation": "Before data collection, specify participant-required exposure contrast and activity checks. If retaining the illustrative model bands, a same-table candidate must simultaneously meet >=0.20 and <=0.05 (or0.001) under a justified measured normalisation. C* cannot be directly treated as tea concentration. Measure and report all four seats and shared-document/speech performance; absence of this contrast is an inconclusive table test, not proof all boundary alternatives fail.",
  "not_learning": true,
  "traffic_note": "Reference door schedule held independently of seating occupancy, not coupled crowd simulation."
}
