{
  "publication": "V118",
  "scope": "Original fixed three-room vestibule/two-layer model. Separate from the final two 72-seat rooms. Normalised model concentration C*, not perceived smell.",
  "units": {
    "supply": "m3/h",
    "share": "fraction of general extraction from lower layer",
    "concentration": "C*"
  },
  "metric": "Largest Room03 whole-room 20-minute mean over each study-specific 128-scenario panel",
  "v116": {
    "rows": 8064,
    "fixed_supply_ml_choices": [
      {
        "key": "fixed_q4320",
        "method": "ml",
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": null,
        "type": "fixed",
        "chosen_index": 20,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.00710567493471015,
        "room03_mean_Cstar": 0.003155393476159927,
        "room03_lower_worst_Cstar": 0.008512839673705511,
        "room03_sampled_peak_Cstar": 0.010215956241307151,
        "nominal_worst_Cstar": 0.009768248291289371,
        "reduction_percent": 27.25742914370343,
        "oracle_index": 20,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_worst_Cstar": 0.00710567493471015,
        "regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "true_feasible_rank": 1,
        "feasible_candidates": 11,
        "captured_fraction": 1.0,
        "constraint_violations": 0,
        "max_increase_Cstar_by_target": [
          -0.09680676491869389,
          -0.004141065448036253,
          -0.00013115648771959822,
          -0.08322360928465011,
          -0.003460217797473372,
          -0.00011225509691308104,
          -0.09694659866023869,
          -0.0035611005001261846,
          -0.00013555861430009997
        ],
        "max_constraint_excess_Cstar": 0.0,
        "predicted_worst_Cstar": 0.007106614763628695,
        "predicted_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "key": "fixed_q4680",
        "method": "ml",
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": null,
        "type": "fixed",
        "chosen_index": 20,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.006139601851468332,
        "room03_mean_Cstar": 0.0027142138614532274,
        "room03_lower_worst_Cstar": 0.0073934821101802675,
        "room03_sampled_peak_Cstar": 0.00889883809720433,
        "nominal_worst_Cstar": 0.008591837413835504,
        "reduction_percent": 28.541456783368798,
        "oracle_index": 20,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_worst_Cstar": 0.006139601851468332,
        "regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "true_feasible_rank": 1,
        "feasible_candidates": 11,
        "captured_fraction": 1.0,
        "constraint_violations": 0,
        "max_increase_Cstar_by_target": [
          -0.09982301405916094,
          -0.0038666436554078143,
          -0.00011853754899650212,
          -0.0845138822543029,
          -0.003212351073046023,
          -0.00010106548012753556,
          -0.09758446228835882,
          -0.003278368818365074,
          -0.00012115703668133168
        ],
        "max_constraint_excess_Cstar": 0.0,
        "predicted_worst_Cstar": 0.00614080510228537,
        "predicted_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "key": "fixed_q5040",
        "method": "ml",
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": null,
        "type": "fixed",
        "chosen_index": 20,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.005357145543068416,
        "room03_mean_Cstar": 0.0023597879712795753,
        "room03_lower_worst_Cstar": 0.006481756110709254,
        "room03_sampled_peak_Cstar": 0.007821235306376602,
        "nominal_worst_Cstar": 0.007620481396536518,
        "reduction_percent": 29.700693902314097,
        "oracle_index": 20,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_worst_Cstar": 0.005357145543068416,
        "regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "true_feasible_rank": 1,
        "feasible_candidates": 11,
        "captured_fraction": 1.0,
        "constraint_violations": 0,
        "max_increase_Cstar_by_target": [
          -0.10221670708132702,
          -0.0036166865782267747,
          -0.00010728262275668091,
          -0.08539261810367949,
          -0.0029889005188250698,
          -8.998264546015284e-05,
          -0.09776130330725463,
          -0.003029276205551534,
          -0.000109092059146165
        ],
        "max_constraint_excess_Cstar": 0.0,
        "predicted_worst_Cstar": 0.005365296684289112,
        "predicted_feasible": true
      }
    ],
    "comparisons": {
      "fixed": {
        "pairs": [
          {
            "key": "fixed_q4320",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": null,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "fixed_q4680",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": null,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "fixed_q5040",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": null,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          }
        ],
        "counts": {
          "ml_lower": 0,
          "interpolation_lower": 0,
          "tie": 3,
          "ml_guard_failure": 0,
          "interpolation_guard_failure": 0
        },
        "same_setting": 3
      },
      "wind_conditional": {
        "pairs": [
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w0",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": -5.37,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w1",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": -3.61,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w2",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": -1.83,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w3",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": -0.41,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w4",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": 0.73,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w5",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": 2.79,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w6",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": 4.17,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4320_w7",
            "supply": 4320.0,
            "wind": 5.53,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w0",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": -5.37,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w1",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": -3.61,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w2",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": -1.83,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w3",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": -0.41,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w4",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": 0.73,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w5",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": 2.79,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w6",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": 4.17,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q4680_w7",
            "supply": 4680.0,
            "wind": 5.53,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w0",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": -5.37,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w1",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": -3.61,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w2",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": -1.83,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w3",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": -0.41,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w4",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": 0.73,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w5",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": 2.79,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w6",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": 4.17,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          },
          {
            "key": "wind_q5040_w7",
            "supply": 5040.0,
            "wind": 5.53,
            "same_setting": true,
            "ml_minus_interpolation_Cstar": 0.0,
            "verdict": "tie"
          }
        ],
        "counts": {
          "ml_lower": 0,
          "interpolation_lower": 0,
          "tie": 24,
          "ml_guard_failure": 0,
          "interpolation_guard_failure": 0
        },
        "same_setting": 24
      }
    },
    "conditional_choice_evidence": [
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": -5.37,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": -3.61,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": -1.83,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": -0.41,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": 0.73,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": 2.79,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": 4.17,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4320.0,
        "wind": 5.53,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": -5.37,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": -3.61,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": -1.83,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": -0.41,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": 0.73,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": 2.79,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": 4.17,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 4680.0,
        "wind": 5.53,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": -5.37,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": -3.61,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": -1.83,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": -0.41,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": 0.73,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": 2.79,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": 4.17,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      },
      {
        "supply": 5040.0,
        "wind": 5.53,
        "interpolation_share": 0.75,
        "ml_share": 0.75,
        "oracle_share": 0.75,
        "interpolation_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "ml_regret_Cstar": 0.0,
        "both_solver_feasible": true
      }
    ]
  },
  "v117": {
    "rows": 4992,
    "ml_choices": [
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.00873184241902388,
        "method": "ml",
        "index": 1,
        "oracle_index": 1,
        "oracle_supply": 4320,
        "supply": 4320,
        "share": 0.625,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.008408786304704189,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 3.6997474166031186,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00032305611431969125,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 1.097032008777997e-05,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 360.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 0.0003356125996494281,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 6.4340207510557535e-06,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006985473935219104,
        "method": "ml",
        "index": 8,
        "oracle_index": 8,
        "oracle_supply": 4440,
        "supply": 4440,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.006865109505834692,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 21.378453980367034,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00012036442938441212,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.0001036722841974514,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 240.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00011517706728250525,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 9.900451423445653e-05,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.0065488818142679095,
        "method": "ml",
        "index": 14,
        "oracle_index": 14,
        "oracle_supply": 4560,
        "supply": 4560,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0065388669194628365,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 25.114693948017823,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 1.001489480507295e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00012176496074974713,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 120.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 6.865656854727724e-06,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.0001175699998987842,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006112289693316716,
        "method": "ml",
        "index": 23,
        "oracle_index": 23,
        "oracle_supply": 4740,
        "supply": 4740,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0060912268048463085,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 30.241219292099437,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 2.1062888470407132e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00014569552576486203,
        "air_saving_m3_h": -60.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 2.2403720236640993e-05,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00014066927293677881,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      }
    ],
    "direct75_choices": [
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.00873184241902388,
        "method": "direct75",
        "index": 2,
        "oracle_index": 1,
        "oracle_supply": 4320,
        "supply": 4320,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.007216270108458338,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 17.35684449897534,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.0015155723105655418,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 8.228090703925166e-05,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 360.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006985473935219104,
        "method": "direct75",
        "index": 8,
        "oracle_index": 8,
        "oracle_supply": 4440,
        "supply": 4440,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.006865109505834692,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 21.378453980367034,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00012036442938441212,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.0001036722841974514,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 240.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.0065488818142679095,
        "method": "direct75",
        "index": 14,
        "oracle_index": 14,
        "oracle_supply": 4560,
        "supply": 4560,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0065388669194628365,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 25.114693948017823,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 1.001489480507295e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00012176496074974713,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 120.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006112289693316716,
        "method": "direct75",
        "index": 23,
        "oracle_index": 23,
        "oracle_supply": 4740,
        "supply": 4740,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0060912268048463085,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 30.241219292099437,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 2.1062888470407132e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00014569552576486203,
        "air_saving_m3_h": -60.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      }
    ],
    "interpolation_choices": [
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.00873184241902388,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "index": 1,
        "oracle_index": 1,
        "oracle_supply": 4320,
        "supply": 4320,
        "share": 0.625,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.008408786304704189,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 3.6997474166031186,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00032305611431969125,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 1.097032008777997e-05,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 360.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 0.0003396710814051098,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 5.685496068229636e-06,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006985473935219104,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "index": 8,
        "oracle_index": 8,
        "oracle_supply": 4440,
        "supply": 4440,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.006865109505834692,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 21.378453980367034,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00012036442938441212,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.0001036722841974514,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 240.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00012558126797439055,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 9.746799192168103e-05,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.0065488818142679095,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "index": 14,
        "oracle_index": 14,
        "oracle_supply": 4560,
        "supply": 4560,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0065388669194628365,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 25.114693948017823,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 1.001489480507295e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00012176496074974713,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 120.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 1.5597296169767537e-05,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00011566724540345674,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006112289693316716,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "index": 23,
        "oracle_index": 23,
        "oracle_supply": 4740,
        "supply": 4740,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0060912268048463085,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 30.241219292099437,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 2.1062888470407132e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00014569552576486203,
        "air_saving_m3_h": -60.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "predicted_feasible": true,
        "predicted_goal_slack_Cstar": 3.2439312875538404e-05,
        "predicted_guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.0001394072463500167,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      }
    ],
    "oracle_choices": [
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.00873184241902388,
        "method": "oracle",
        "index": 1,
        "oracle_index": 1,
        "oracle_supply": 4320,
        "supply": 4320,
        "share": 0.625,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.008408786304704189,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 3.6997474166031186,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00032305611431969125,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 1.097032008777997e-05,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 360.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006985473935219104,
        "method": "oracle",
        "index": 8,
        "oracle_index": 8,
        "oracle_supply": 4440,
        "supply": 4440,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.006865109505834692,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 21.378453980367034,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 0.00012036442938441212,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.0001036722841974514,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 240.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.0065488818142679095,
        "method": "oracle",
        "index": 14,
        "oracle_index": 14,
        "oracle_supply": 4560,
        "supply": 4560,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0065388669194628365,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 25.114693948017823,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 1.001489480507295e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00012176496074974713,
        "air_saving_m3_h": 120.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "cap_Cstar": 0.006112289693316716,
        "method": "oracle",
        "index": 23,
        "oracle_index": 23,
        "oracle_supply": 4740,
        "supply": 4740,
        "share": 0.75,
        "solver_feasible": true,
        "goal_pass": true,
        "guard_violations": 0,
        "room03_worst_Cstar": 0.0060912268048463085,
        "room03_reduction_percent": 30.241219292099437,
        "goal_slack_Cstar": 2.1062888470407132e-05,
        "guard_min_slack_Cstar": 0.00014569552576486203,
        "air_saving_m3_h": -60.0,
        "excess_air_vs_oracle_m3_h": 0,
        "shared_reference_queries": 128
      }
    ],
    "comparisons": [
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "verdict": "same_air",
        "same_setting": true,
        "ml_minus_interpolation_air": 0
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "verdict": "same_air",
        "same_setting": true,
        "ml_minus_interpolation_air": 0
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "verdict": "same_air",
        "same_setting": true,
        "ml_minus_interpolation_air": 0
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "verdict": "same_air",
        "same_setting": true,
        "ml_minus_interpolation_air": 0
      }
    ],
    "query_accounting": [
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "ml",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "retained75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "maximum75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "reference",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 128,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "direct75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.0,
        "method": "oracle",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 4992,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "ml",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "retained75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "maximum75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "reference",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 128,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "direct75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 512,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.2,
        "method": "oracle",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 4992,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "ml",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "retained75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "maximum75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "reference",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 128,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "direct75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 768,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.25,
        "method": "oracle",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 4992,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "interpolation",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "ml",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "retained75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "maximum75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 256,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "reference",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 128,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "direct75",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 1152,
        "reference_queries": 128
      },
      {
        "reduction_goal": 0.3,
        "method": "oracle",
        "total_distinct_queries_with_shared_reference": 4992,
        "reference_queries": 128
      }
    ],
    "query_scope": "Distinct logical original-solver requests including shared reference. Cached reference is counted once, including for oracle/reference. The result field online_candidate_validation_queries is a gross menu-request count; do not add it to reference costs without overlap removal. These are not extra executed audits. The gross online_candidate_validation_queries field is omitted from this public extract."
  },
  "prior_ml_adoption_gate": "Failed; scaled interpolation remains the default. No new fitting.",
  "provenance": {
    "116": {
      "results_sha256": "355736481ae07cb513c04290909e12b5a9e43e97f47ead06ba4c2f9211933d14",
      "protocol_sha256": "b969a2a60f081fe773c34b98db00cba2ab10eb3076384c1241b7c7228e09d6a4",
      "verification_sha256": "cdeb884cf093b1c6e983263784067505d6cb75e990ae8452d8600961630c733e"
    },
    "117": {
      "results_sha256": "79c61eadd545ee6ff5bd5932e3dfec2db48fc10716365364f1a91231c877bf34",
      "protocol_sha256": "f2a8ea5627e9c194ede6d2deebd74728cec1c621dc371bc766dc3eff41be047a",
      "verification_sha256": "a8a1fc1af3e87061243a334630c595fb0ca54903cf5f2e7ea463e67ee58a70d1"
    }
  },
  "unchanged_plates": {
    "Ventilation_Decision.png": "b29c1be026f002a7eb24ee33376f67e3be39abadb51e47b7149e6beae32a438b",
    "Ventilation_Decision.svg": "29aeda8fa29ccd755ebbe7bbc1b77897a42cb4182d1025eaa40b9624414b7e7d",
    "Minimum_Air_Decision.png": "f3f10b16b0993b65d3348646ec95d89812cdc0e2c14916b8d425552950aeca8d",
    "Minimum_Air_Decision.svg": "7550ae8db32c49f25564410efec13ee7bb12034b6be067daeca2c80e60478f69"
  },
  "publication_note": "Selected aggregate values copied from verified results. This public extract is not the original protocol or full reproduction bundle. Source hashes identify unchanged private originals; local paths, raw fields and model weights are excluded."
}
