SCENT COMMONS / SPATIAL CONCLUSION V115 / V118 VENTILATION ADDENDUM

More seat choices, conditional exposure

The retained design creates more qualifying seat choices under the declared virtual model and gives a separately recounted N1 visibility result. A shorter journey does not guarantee lower cumulative or peak exposure. The final geometry stays fixed. The largest tested shortcut that keeps the old visibility passes saves 11.8 mm and adds no qualifying profile.

The question remains: can people with different scent requirements move to another seat and rejoin a shared activity? The evidence supports additional modelled choices, with unresolved profiles and sightline conditions. It does not establish a universal reduction in smell, a validated human experience, or an overall advantage of curved over straight rooms.

One-page English A3 · Published aggregate evidence · How this was checked

Black A3, approved final-room section at left, separate profile gains, visibility and simulated exposure graphs at right

Three spatial questions, three denominators

QuestionUnit and comparisonWhat the result supportsWhat it does not establish
Who gains a qualifying seat?7,490 virtual profiles per origin. C1 and F1b have different stage baselines.Combined access, travel, seated-exposure and social-view rules.A count of participants, or a profile result rescored using moving exposure.
Can the N1 mark be seen?574 configurations = 41 chair locations x 14 S1 postures; eight trips each.Specified geometric sample visibility through the saved motions.Recognition, attention or a 451-person success count.
How does moving exposure change?Matched old/final model pairs within each declared air, timing and waiting condition.Head-centre C* (normalised model concentration, not dose or perceived smell) integrals and maxima over equal paired observation windows.Inhaled dose, perceived smell, physical validity or a combined success probability.

There is no defined assignment from the virtual profiles to visibility configurations or dynamic exposure conditions. These populations are not added, multiplied or averaged into a single score. Links lead to public explanations and aggregate results. Detailed source records and native models remain in the private working archive. The moving-exposure study has not been fed back into the original eligibility rule; the original choice gains remain claims under that rule.

1. Keep the selected design and its original choice gains

N1 remains 556 mm forward / 30.0 mm right in both final native models. Approximately 29.02 mm remains an experimental visibility boundary. C1 retains its 30 mm walking lead-in; F1b retains the N1-specific departure turn at 150 mm, with the shared turn retained for five other destinations. The saved native files and left section show a return snapshot, not every tested or resting chair configuration.

OriginOriginal cohortStage-baseline unmetGain in all relevant settingsConditional gainsStill without a qualifying optionFinal qualifying
C1 / central walk7,490122210 on central walk; offset panel separate1017,389 on the central walk
F1b7,4907332687,420 throughout the declared fixed-150-mm panel; 2 additional conditional

C1 compares 122 previously unmet profiles with 21 new qualifying choices and 101 remaining unmet on the central walk. Its 21 gains persist in 361 saved outward/return offset pairs. That separate offset panel leaves 101 unmet in 235 pairs and 100 unmet in 126 pairs; those offset-dependent extra choices are not folded into the central-walk bar or summed as distinct profiles. F1b compares 73 previously unmet profiles with 3 gains throughout the fixed-150-mm panel, 2 conditional gains and 68 never qualifying. Each conditional profile passes at only three of 41 chair positions. There are no losses among previously qualifying profiles in these route-stage comparisons.

Earlier airflow and chair changes had their own baseline gains: 153 for the C1 local-airflow intervention and 37 for the F1b chair/sightline intervention. They remain historical design-selection evidence, not extra independent confirmations or a combined population rate. Across the separate 140/150/160-mm F1b exploratory panel, only two new profiles pass everywhere; that is not the fixed-150-mm result above.

OriginOriginal complete trip (m)Retained complete trip (m)Interpretation
C117.81103316.810815Full chair/body cycle; no direct inference to exposure or real walking time
F1b14.16265413.573599Full chair/body cycle; no direct inference to exposure or real walking time

2. Keep N1 visibility separate and nested

The main criterion requires at least 18/35 visible points throughout frames 57-83 on all four higher-torso trips and at least 306 passing frames on each of four broader-body trips. Eight trips cover two rooms, two occupancies and two body types. The frame-804 check is an additional condition within the main-pass set.

CriterionCount out of all 574Relationship
Main eight-trip criterion451123 fail the broader-body duration condition
Also frame 804 on all four broader trips369Nested within 451; 82 main passes miss this extra condition

All 574 configurations pass the higher-torso departure window. The 123 main failures are all 41 chair positions under each of three S1 poses: back 30 mm, left 20 mm, and torso tilt -2 degrees forward / -2 degrees right. The other 11 postures pass the main criterion at all 41 chair positions. This is geometric visibility of sampled points, not a test of sign reading or human satisfaction.

3. Whole-journey exposure: the broad comparison

The A3 ranges use one matched comparison panel for both C1 and F1b: V107 primary42, six frozen air conditions, both rooms, two bodies, three overall speeds, 42 departure phases, 60/1,200-second minimum destination dwell and both spare-time policies. There are 24,192 pairs after verifying and removing identical occupancy copies (12,096 per origin). The frozen exposure fields do not react to the changed occupancy: these copies do not constitute an airflow or moving-crowd effect test. The separate held-door supplement and later clock/setup panels are not pooled into these ranges.

Each percentage is 100 x (final - old) / old for the same pair and metric. Negative is lower. These are finite envelopes of simulated conditions, not confidence intervals or field-error bounds. The numerical tie threshold is 1e-9 percentage points; it is not a physical uncertainty or perceptual threshold. The largest F1b increases are about +0.030% for the integral and +0.097% for the peak. Their signs are numerical findings in frozen fields; no quantified model/field uncertainty interval establishes their physical or perceptual significance. Cumulative integral, whole-window peak and all-motion peak answer different questions; a lower integral can coexist with a higher peak.

OriginMetricPairsMinimum %Maximum %Lower / tie / higher
C1Cumulative integral12096-7.586+15.4386140 / 0 / 5956
C1Whole-window peak12096-1.975+1.2312135 / 9335 / 626
C1All-motion peak12096-7.487+1.2313296 / 8174 / 626
F1bCumulative integral12096-4.840+0.03011115 / 0 / 981
F1bWhole-window peak12096-15.409+0.0979572 / 2272 / 252
F1bAll-motion peak12096-15.409+0.09710384 / 1144 / 568

On the A3, the blue bar and printed values show the five non-Dlow fields; grey extensions show how including Dlow expands the envelope. The non-Dlow panel has 20,160 pairs, versus 24,192 in the full six-field panel. Dlow endpoints often have small old-arm denominators, so a large percentage is not a comparable absolute concentration change. Both Dlow fields are fresh same-solver recomputations whose strict original-archive reproduction checks failed. That limitation stays unresolved. Excluding Dlow, both origins still include cumulative and whole-window peak increases in the primary panel:

OriginMetricNon-Dlow pairsMinimum %Maximum %
C1Cumulative integral10080-2.849+5.041
C1Whole-window peak10080-1.331+1.231
F1bCumulative integral10080-1.345+0.030
F1bWhole-window peak10080-6.838+0.097

The negative and positive extrema can come from different conditions. These envelopes do not identify one best operating policy or show what is typical. The full endpoint identities and old-arm denominators are retained in the data ledger.

Where the saved time is spent matters

“Origin spare” places the time saved by the final trip back at its origin; “destination spare” places it at the destination. This is a scheduling assumption, not observed behaviour. Both arms use the same observation time within each comparison.

OriginSpare-time locationMetricPairsMinimum %Maximum %Lower / tie / higher
C1originCumulative integral6048-0.075+15.43892 / 0 / 5956
C1originWhole-window peak6048-1.975+1.2312135 / 3287 / 626
C1destinationCumulative integral6048-7.586-0.0001756048 / 0 / 0
C1destinationWhole-window peak6048000 / 6048 / 0
F1boriginCumulative integral6048-2.514+0.0215767 / 0 / 281
F1boriginWhole-window peak6048-15.409+0.0974786 / 1136 / 126
F1bdestinationCumulative integral6048-4.840+0.0305348 / 0 / 700
F1bdestinationWhole-window peak6048-14.329+0.0974786 / 1136 / 126

4. What the later sensitivity studies add

StudyDeclared coverageConclusionBoundary
V108 / C1 clocks108,864 pairs / 12,096 base identities / nine turn-posture clocksAll 54,432 destination-spare integrals decrease; whole-window peaks tie. Across the full base set, 96 integral and 429 peak comparisons reverse sign relative to the baseline clock.C1 only. Hypothetical clocks; endpoint and path/timing accounting remain explicit.
V109 / chair and start241,920 baseline-clock pairs. F1b: 41 centred chair points plus three extra starts at five points (56 configurations). C1: four starts.4 C1 and 19 F1b reference cases have near-zero integral sign reversals under selected setup changes.Not a full 41-chair x all-posture x all-clock crossing.
V110 / selected combined timing23 frozen reversal identities, matched controls and a peak witness; 1,008 primary + 2,016 diagnostic pairsEndpoint alignment preserves 20/23 reversals; changed clocks retain 0-8/20. Setup-effect direction stays the same in 32/32 C1 and 152/152 F1b changed-clock seed entries.Near-zero paired signs differ from setup contrasts. Selected witnesses cannot certify the full panel.

V109 uses fixed speed factor 1 and the baseline turn/posture clock, unlike the three-speed V107 panel. The factor levels and full grid were checked directly against all 241,920 saved V109 rows. Its counts are (4 C1 + 41 centred F1b + 3 extra starts x 5 F1b chair points) x 2 rooms x 2 bodies x 6 fields x 42 phases x 2 dwells x 2 spare policies = 241,920. The five centred F1b points are already among the 41, so they are not added twice. The V110 result refines the interpretation rather than moving the N1 mark again: a common clock shift can move both setups across zero while their relative setup effect keeps its direction. Sampling checks and small residuals verify calculations within frozen fields; they do not establish perceptual importance or physical field accuracy.

5. The design-evidence chain

The following retained V104 chain is historical model evidence with its original stage baselines. The whole-journey exposure evidence above extends the research separately; it does not silently alter these original eligibility results.

Design stageC1F1bEvidence / limitationSource
Scope and shared inputs7,490 matched virtual profiles; C1 origin.The same count per F1b origin, evaluated separately.Public scent ratings support preference variation. Seat-choice rules, movement budgets and social requirements are model assumptions. No addition across origins.
Profile totals and room-specific identity records agree.
V47 cohort results
Earlier design gainsThe local airflow intervention had already added 153 qualifying profiles; V44 retained those gains across its declared error panel.The V30 chair / mutual-sightline change added 37 qualifying profiles under its own baseline.These historical increments are separate from the final route gains of 21 and 3 + 2 conditional. They are not a combined population success rate.
V44 retained-ID record and V30 gain/loss metrics are linked; V30 reports zero losses. Different stage baselines are preserved.
Airflow retention · Earlier chair gains
Room and chair geometryMatched 72-seat curved B and straight B′ rooms; inherited furniture and body models.N1 chair yaw +95°; S1 yaw −75°, shifted 103 mm. 41 tested N1 chair positions.Two native models retain the tested room geometry. Their saved return snapshots must be distinguished from resting-seat datums.
140 unchanged native chairs and four documented snapshot poses verified. All 144 resting datums reconstructed and matched.
Native / exposure check
DepartureRetained V45 starting-pose correction and its declared reading-error model.The same inherited start checks. A dedicated N1 turn is 150 mm along the original aisle; the shared mark remains for five other destinations.Earlier entry and whole-body tests are inherited. The route edit is checked against those same gates.
V56 input and geometry fingerprints match. Shared-route evidence is unchanged.
Starting conditions · Shared marks
Walk and return17.811 → 16.811 m. Retain the 30 mm walking lead-in. Outward and return offsets span −9 to +9 mm.14.163 → 13.574 m at the 150 mm turn. All 41 destination-chair positions are represented.Lengths include full chair and body cycles. Each user’s additional departure preparation is included by the original scorer.
2,888 saved C1 combined-trip records pass and restore; all 21 gains held in 361 offset pairs. 328 F1b route records match V56 lengths and V90 motion identities.
C1 save result · Cross-study audit
Scent exposure at seatsC1–N3 seated exposure assessed against the origin and the declared scent preference rule.F1b–N1 sampled at each of the 41 chair positions, with both readouts.Retain 18.5 + 5.5 m³/h transfer, 0.5 s solver panel and nine signed errors. Exposure is the archived seated exposure quantity (model C*, not inhaled dose). Moving-path exposure is outside this score.
288 field hashes match. The producer’s 12 fixed seat IDs and 41 N1 coordinates per room match the correct resting / displaced datums. All field arrays use those same indices.
Operating decision · Coordinate contract
Activity and mutual sightlinesRetained seat-menu activity and sightline requirements.Two reciprocal peer links and the retained shared-board checks. A third peer link was not achieved under the fixed constraints.These are geometric line-of-sight rules, separate from reading a sign or observing a conversation.
The planar N1 graphic lies below the existing peer/board ray height range. It is a display surface, with no added solid obstacle in the motion model.
Peer-view study · Cue bounds
Qualifying choices122 unmet at the V47 stage baseline → 21 newly qualifying + 101 still unmet on the central walk. 7,389 of 7,490 qualify there.73 unmet at the V56 stage baseline → 3 newly qualifying in all settings + 2 conditional + 68 never qualifying. 7,420 of 7,490 qualify in every tested setting at the fixed 150 mm turn.Zero earlier qualifying profiles lost their choice in either comparison. C1’s 21 and F1b’s 3 use different starting baselines. The two conditional F1b profiles each pass at only three of 41 chair positions.
Arithmetic, identical room IDs and the original gain/loss records agree. Across the separate 140/150/160 mm panel, only two new F1b profiles qualify everywhere; three are conditional.
C1 decision · Fixed 150 mm result · Three-position result

V112–V114 / REMAINING MOVEMENT BUDGETS

Small shortcuts do not resolve the remaining profiles.

The original movement caps stay fixed. A saved-score audit found 3 C1 and 47 F1b profiles in the travel-budget-only relief group. These are subsets of the 101 C1 and 68 F1b profiles still without a qualifying option. They are not counts of real participants.

The five closest F1b profiles needed 365–483 mm less travel to pass across all saved contexts. A 519.7 mm shortcut could meet their original travel scores, but failed the required broader-body visibility duration at all 41 centred-S1 chair settings: 287 frames against the unchanged 306-frame threshold. It was rejected.

The next search measured 169 declared inputs, including every 1 mm origin station from 150 to 300 mm and 18 grip combinations. The largest tested shortcut retaining the same 451 main and 369 nested frame-804 identities saves only 11.782 mm per full trip. This is a maximum within that discrete search, not a global or continuous optimum.

An 11.8 mm feasible saving is much smaller than the 353–471 mm still required by the five closest virtual profiles.

The 39.269 mm centred-S1 alternative retains only 369 of the old 451 main passes and 331 of the old 369 nested passes. Its 17 new nested passes cannot replace the old identities lost. It also adds none of the five profiles. Neither comparison is adopted.

Retain the current final route and N1 at 556 mm forward / 30.0 mm right. At the all-set 11.782 mm candidate, each of the five profiles still passes 0 of its 2,952 saved contexts; its worst-context shortfall remains 353–471 mm. F1b remains 7,420 always qualifying, 2 conditional and 68 never qualifying. C1 remains 7,389 qualifying and 101 unmet. No moving-exposure calculation or eligibility threshold was changed.

Further decimal refinement is not the next research need. A future design experiment would need a materially different path or layout with enough potential saving to meet those remaining budgets, while preserving departure, collision, return and visibility. This synthesis does not propose or validate that new design.

V112 / original budget gaps · V113 / rejected half-metre shortcut · V114 / smaller-route comparison · Aggregate results

A separate ventilation decision test

V116 and V117 return to the original three-room model. Simulator-trained ML predicts room concentrations to select ventilation settings, then the original simulator verifies the choices. At 4,680 m³/h supply, the selected split reduces the worst Room 03 mean by 28.5%. A separate minimum-air test meets the reference target with 7.7% less supply. These are different tests, not a combined improvement.

ML and interpolation choose the same settings. Direct 75% search reaches the same minimum supplies, with a different extraction split for the primary goal. The earlier ML adoption gate remains failed. None of these figures changes the two-room spatial results on this page.

Read the data, choices, tie-rule caveat and finite-menu limits →

6. What is finished and what remains

StatusResult or remaining work
Complete within the declared modelFinal native design and N1 set-out; original route-stage profile gains; separate visibility recount; broad moving-exposure comparisons; clock and selected setup sensitivity; this integrated conclusion.
Remaining model failures101 C1 profiles and 68 F1b profiles have no qualifying option under their original comparison, plus 2 conditional F1b profiles. N1 has 123 main failures and 82 additional frame-804 misses among main passes.
Unresolved evidence limitsDlow strict archive mismatches; physical/perceptual validity; sensitivity outside the declared field, phase, chair and posture grids. No joint profile-visibility-exposure assignment or dynamic re-scoring rule.
Publication and future workThis consolidated conclusion is the current public account. The native models and detailed evidence are retained privately. V112–V114 now close the declared smaller-route search. Any future design experiment must target a substantial remaining travel deficit and rerun the relevant gates; a smaller numerical boundary search would not resolve these five profiles.

Verification and provenance

The earlier V111 synthesis re-read 48,384 V107 rows and verified identical occupancy copies before counting 24,192 unique comparisons. It checked the full 241,920-row V109 condition grid and the later timing aggregates. It retained the earlier visibility recount and verified 2,902 source-file hashes, including both final Rhino models. V115 checks the retained aggregates and 2,335 prior-version file hashes. No new simulation or physical experiment was run for this publication synthesis; V113 and V114 did run the separately documented motion and visibility replays.

Codex prepared and checked the synthesis; Claude reviewed its presentation and calculation summaries within a bounded scope. Their agreement is not physical validation. The V115 A3 retains the V111 room section and three distinct graphs, adding the V112–V114 travel-budget conclusion. These later studies do not alter the final design or add qualifying profiles. Detailed source code, model archives and review receipts remain private. The downloadable aggregate evidence records the displayed exposure ranges and their population definitions.

Download aggregate evidence · Browse the earlier research record